See also the main article on Massachusetts, for documented election integrity issues and further reports.

Former US military intelligence officer and statistical analyst Seth Keshel analyzed the trends of voter registrations versus actual votes. The following report indicates which counties’ vote counts align with the trend in voter registrations and which have small or large divergences. Each county is flagged as red, yellow, or green, based on whether the 2020 vote totals aligned with the expected trends (as past decades demonstrate they typically do), or if they diverged in statistically unlikely ways.

Seth Keshel County Trend Map for Massachusetts

Chart legend: Red = Rampant Fraud, Yellow = Likely/Suspect, Green = Clean

Seth Keshel County Trends for Massachusetts

Trump votes Biden votes Other votes
Officially reported results 1167202 (32.1%) 2382202 (65.6%) 83522 (2.3%)
Estimate of potential fraud 235000 (6.5%)
Estimate of actual result
(with fraud removed)
1167202 (34.4%) 2147202 (63.2%) 83522 (2.5%)

Democrat nominees have been stuck in the 1.9 million range for three consecutive elections, including mega-popular Obama. Since 2016, 11 of the 14 counties have trended Republican in registration, including Suffolk (Boston). The state is 1.5% more Republican than in 2016, which would suggest a tighter election result, depending on the 2016 third party distribution. No counties have been red here since 1988, although trends suggest that that likely would have changed in 2020.

Biden has at least 235,000 more votes than the trends would reasonably suggest. Here are the highlights:

County Excess Votes
Middlesex 50k
Worcester 35k
Norfolk 30k
Plymouth 30k
Essex 25k
Bristol 25k

Suffolk isn’t far off trend. Dukes and Nantucket are clean, which offers some clarity on the ground-game of the fraud, since they’re not on the mainland.

If Biden is 235k heavy, Biden’s real margin would be 63.2% to 34.4%, or 980k votes.


Top 100 Worst Counties

Seth has listed Massachusetts’s Middlesex County as being among the Nation’s Top 100 Worst Counties in terms of abnormal trends during the 2020 election.

Caroline Colarusso’s Investigations

Seth and team,

Allow me to introduce myself my name is Caroline Colarusso and I was a candidate for Congress in 2020 for the fifth district of Massachusetts. I ran against the Asst. Speaker of the house Katherine Clark.

I have been communicating the serious concerns we have uncovered for the 11/3 election in Massachusetts to major Boston media outlets & Sirius radio. (See links below)

Through FIOA and public requests request and through communications from whistle blowers we have been told there are in excess of 500,000 ballot applications returned to sender sitting in the Archives Building in Boston. We have recently gained access to examine these ballot applications via a public records request. A total of 3.6 million ballot applications were mailed to so-called voters in Massachusetts. Between 12 and 20 percent were sent to bad addresses.

Source: Telegram Post, Sept 1, 2021. (Apologies for the low quality image.)


Seth Keshel’s estimates are based on the percentage of voters who are registered to each party (where it’s possible to obtain this information) compared to the actual votes for each party. He examined these party trends over the last two decades, as well as population growth, which brought to light the strange and statistically unlikely outliers and anomalies that occurred in 2020. We explain this process, step by step, with visual examples, in our guide How to Predict Election Results Using Registration Data, so that you can investigate the numbers for yourself.

This video from Telegram also explains some of Seth’s approach to analyzing precincts.

Raw Data

We aim to publish links to both the raw election data and voter registration data for Massachusetts so that citizens and researchers can analyze this information for themselves.

Show Raw Data Links

Certified Election Results
Currently unknown

In most states, the certified election results are available from the Secretary of State or State Board of Elections. Check their website for details. States are also required by HAVA law to inform the public of how many absentee ballots were both sent and received to uniformed services and overseas voters.
Voter Registration Rolls/Database
Currently unknown

In some states, these are freely available from the Secretary of State or State Board of Elections. Check their website. In other states, voter rolls must be purchased and/or accessed via a signed legal agreement. Some officials are also obstructing access to the rolls, to make auditing difficult. Let us know via Telegram or via the comment section below if you experience issues.
Cast Vote Records Ordros Analytics has collated a repository of Cast Vote Records (CVRs) which list everyone who voted in the Nov 2020 election. Only some counties in some states are represented, but the list is growing.
The New York Times 2020 Election Results Results for all states, with several maps and charts.
Data Explorer Tool Our own tool for inspecting the 2020 New York Times data, including the time-series data of how the counting progressed. Also provides download links for raw JSON or CSV data, including counts for every precinct and county.
US Election Atlas
Recommended when doing trend analysis, as shown on this page

Detailed results for 2020 and previous years. Some data is freely accessible on their website, while some, such as detailed historic results in CSV format, are purchasable for a fee.
This appears to be the source commonly used by Seth Keshel for his analysis, although we have not officially confirmed this.
2020 General Election Data & Research A broad collection of national stats, vote and registration counts, time-series data, voting machine information and manuals, PDF reports, and other research collated by citizen auditors.
Election Night Time-Series Data from Edison

Provides more detail than is available from the New York Times, and includes numerous interactive charts.
Download ZIP of Raw Data
Published by Jeff O’Donnell,
Weekly HAVV SSN Reports

Social Security Administration (SSA) Weekly Data for Help America Vote Verification (HAVV) Transactions by State.
Learn more about this data
Published by Jeff O’Donnell,

If you have additional sources of election data, please let us know via Telegram, Twitter or post a comment below to assist.

Other Reports

Get Involved

Volunteers are needed to help verify the irregularities found. One key way this is done is through voter canvassing, with teams analyzing the county and state records and voter rolls, and others going door-to-door to identify whether the records match the actual residents living at the address.

Learn more about Canvassing Volunteer in Your State

Election Audit Groups on Telegram

Further updates from Seth Keshel can be found on his Telegram Channel @RealSKeshel.

To join the grassroots efforts in pursuing election integrity and audits of the 2020 election in Massachusetts, you can join the following groups on Telegram:

For other states, see our Full List of Telegram Channels. and Seth Keshel have no affiliation with nor any responsibility for these channels. Discern carefully, as some users and even admins of channels have shown obstruction to transparent audits of our elections.

Visitor Comments

Show Comments